Thomas
Churchyard 1798-1865
The Man
Born in Melton, the only child
of Jonathan Churchyard, butcher and meat trader
and Ann White of Peasenhall. The Napoleonic wars
which lasted from 1799 until 1815 formed the back
drop to Thomas' childhood, and the source of his
father's successful business. When it became clear
that Thomas was intelligent, Jonathan was happy
to spend some of his new wealth on a good education,
hoping to raise him above the yeoman's life of
his forebears.
School - In 1808 Thomas went to Dedham Grammar
School, living in the Headmaster's house as a
boarder. He studied Classics, French and English
poets, philosophy, religious speculation and natural
history. John Constable was an old boy of this
school, from two decades earlier, and was often
found sketching in the Dedham Vale during these
summers.
Articles - In 1815 Thomas left school and the
following year became an articled solicitor with
Crabbe and Cross at Halesworth. Thomas left Halesworth
for London in 1820, to complete his final year
of articles. There he was admitted to the Roll,
an attorney, to the great pride of his parents
and Grandparents.
Collecting - During his time
at Halesworth Thomas learned more than the law.
He travelled to Norwich and there he would have
seen works by John Crome and his son John Berney
Crome. He began to copy their paintings and from
this study to develop his own style of natural
landscapes. He also illustrated a book of botanical
subjects with William Hooker, talented botanical
draughtsman and later Director of Kew Gardens.
He had probably already begun collecting works
of his favourite artists, an addiction which never
left him, even when he later fell on hard times.
After qualifying he took a little free time before
starting work. In London he visited the exhibitions
at the Academy, in 1821 he would have seen Hjohn
Constable's Haywain. He was profoundly influenced
by the work of his fellow Suffolk artist.
Family - He married in 1825
Harriet Hailes, a neighbour of his family in Melton.
Their first child Thomas, was born a few months
later. They set up home in Well Street (now called
Seckford Street), Woodbridge, a small red brick
semi-detached Georgian house. The following year
Ellen was born and the family had begun its expansion,
Emma following in 1828.
Changing fortune - While his
young family grew, his reputation as the Poacher's
Lawyer established itself, and he began to exhibit
at the Norwich Society. The works were praised
and he was elected an Honorary member of the Institution.
Finding himself reasonably well off, having inherited
money from his Great Uncle Charles and his Grandfather
Jonathan, Thomas began to think of trying his
hand at painting for a living.
Acclaim - In 1830 Laura was
born and Thomas began to exhibit in London, at
the Society of British Artists in Suffolk Street.
The following year 1831 sending more works. But
to further his ambition he made plans to move
his young family to Melton, to sell his books
and some of his collection of paintings by Gainsborough,
Crome and George Morland. 1832 brought child number
five Anna, and further exhibitions in London and
Ipswich. Thomas was a founded member of the newly
formed Ipswich Society of Professional and Amateur
Artists. Another member was Edward FitzGerald,
later to become a great friend. Thomas sent works
to the Royal Academy but they were not hung, he
had better luck at the Society of British Artists.
Career change - He took the
plunge and sold off the household furniture and
set off to make his career as a professional artist
in London, together with a neighbour and friend
George Rowe. Unfortunately the public were not
ready for natural landscapes, as John Constable
could have told Thomas. He was struggling too,
although he had been working for so much longer
and had already gained some reputation. Perry
Nursey was in financial trouble and John Berney
Crome went bankrupt. Thomas joined the Society
of Painters in Water-colour.
And back again - In 1833 he
drew the experiment to a close, returning to his
family, and recommencing his career in law. Collecting
his children together once more, the family moved
into The Beeches in Melton, and he opened a makeshift
office in Quay Street, Woodbridge, taking newly
qualified Edwin Church Everitt as his partner.
Having more success as a solicitor the practise
thrived and in 1834 moved to a part of Marsden
House, Cumberland Street (Everitt living in the
rest of the house). Bessie was born, child number
six; and another inheritance came from Aunt Ann.
Routine - Thomas settled down
into a new routine. He worked hard but he never
stopped painting and drawing at every opportunity,
for his own pleasure. He continued to buy paintings,
which he admired and copied, from any source available.
He made contacts and found many bargains as he
travelled to the Courts, and he journeyed to auctions
when there was a gem to pick-up. He formed a deep
friendship with the Quaker poet Bernard Barton,
who lived in Cumberland Street and worked in the
Bank.
Jonathan Churchyard died and once again an inheritance
bolstered his finances and allowed for more purchases.
More of the same - Harriet
arrived in 1836, and Thomas took on a new partner,
Daniel Charles Meadows. The practise moved to
the Market Hill. In 1837 Queen Victoria came to
the throne and John Constable died. Bernard Barton
became friends with Edward FitzGerald, living
at this time at Boulge. So Thomas renewed his
acquaintance with the young aristocrat and found
a fellow art lover to share his passion. Baby
number eight, Charles was born and died within
a few months. Katherine or Kate followed in 1839.
Changes - Edwin Church Everitt
moved to Yarmouth in 1841 and a couple of years
later Meadows went his own way, leaving Thomas
to practise on his own. The birth of their last
child Charley in 1841 meant that the family urgently
needed more room. So in 1843 they left The Beeches
in Melton and moved into Marsden House. From there
Thomas worked with just a couple of clerks. He
preferred attorney's work and avoided taking solicitor's
or commissioning work. The household also included
domestic staff, including a governess to teach
the children. Young Tom Churchyard had at fifteen
or sixteen rejected his father's career and looking
back to his yeoman ancestry, he longed to be a
farmer. He stood a good chance of inheriting various
tenancies from his uncles, so he went to a local
academy which specialised in a scientific approach
to farming. Thomas' mother died and again he inherited
money.
Girls to school - At this point
in his life Thomas was quite well-off, and he
decided that his daughters needed to receive further
education. Ellen, Emma and Laura went to Bury
St Edmunds to a boarding academy. Ellen was almost
too old but Thomas wanted her to have at least
one term. She soon returned home to look after
her Mother who was not well, and to run the busy
house-hold. As the years passed a daughter came
home and another went to the academy, a relay
of Churchyard maidens.
Wits of Woodbridge - At supper
one December evening Edward FitzGerald coined
the phrase 'the Wits of Woodbridge' to ironically
describe the meetings which they enjoyed. Bernard
Barton, Thomas Churchyard, Edward FitzGerald and
Rev. George Crabbe (son of the famous poet) had
fallen into an easy friendship. They met at each
other's houses to eat and drink and chat about
the local news, the arts, the great and the good.
They were an odd group, ages ranging from 35 to
60 and finances ranging just as widely. Barton
was a friend to all, FitzGerald an eccentric who
refused to speak at all to anyone he didn't like.
Churchyard and Barton were of yeoman and trade
stock, while George Crabb and FitzGerald had notable
family connections and were well off.
Loss - By 1849 Bernard Barton
had died, and by mischance FitzGerald found himself
engaged to his daughter Lucy. He had promised
to look after her and it had been misunderstood
as a proposal of marriage. He was too honourable
to refuse her and so followed a number of difficult
years when the old friends were not so often found
together.
Disappointment - In 1850 the
Suffolk Fine Art Association was formed and Thomas
acted as local secretary. Although he had been
very disillusioned by local art associations in
the past, he tried once more, and yet again he
received little recognition from the critics.
He never exhibited there again. After a couple
of years the Norwich painters boycotted the exhibition
as well and staged their own. Thomas sent eight
studies to Norwich and received much praise. It
seemed that Suffolk favoured the contrived landscapes
of the time, not appreciating naturalistic, living
landscapes. Thomas believed that quick sketches
could be works of art in their own right, his
trees swayed in the breeze, his leaves glistened
in the rain.
Money troubles - Young Tom,
disappointed at the long wait for his chance to
farm, decided to see something of the world. In
1852 he set out for America for about six years.
Some of the family's wealth seemed to have evaporated,
and Thomas found from time to time that he hit
cash problems. But the following year the Churchyards
holiday'd in Weston Super Mare, a break from their
usual trips to Aldeburgh, Dunwich or Felixstowe,
maybe a last fling before they had to tighten
their belts.
Changes - An inventory of his
possessions made in 1854 lists the art collection
which he had accumulated. He owned works by Gainsborough
and Constable, Crome, George Morland, Richard
Wilson, Turner, Stothard, Dunthorne, Rowe, Rubens
and Etty. The family had to leave Marsden House
and moved back to Melton for a year or two, to
retrench. But by 1856 they returned to Woodbridge,
to Hamblin House a little further down Cumberland
Street and almost opposite Marsden House. During
this period of financial troubles his friend Edward
FitzGerald had married Lucy Barton and within
a year realised that he could not bear it, they
had separated and FitzGerald returned to even
deeper seclusion in Woodbridge.
Tragedy - Young Tom returned
from America and took over farming at Byng Hall
on the death of his Great Uncle Isaac. But his
great expectations came to very little, Isaac
died intestate and in debt. By the time his estate
was disentangled there was very little left for
Thomas or Tom. In 1858 Tom married Elizabeth Bardwell,
his cousin, Isaac's illegitimate daughter. They
had a son in 1860, Very Young Tom; 1861 a second
son Charles; and later a daughter Laura. After
four years of struggling with the farm, young
Tom took his family to Canada to find a new start.
But the ship which they took from Liverpool to
Quebec foundered on the coast of Newfoundland.
Tom survived but Elizabeth and all of the children
were lost.
Preparation - By 1865 Thomas
was beginning to be troubled by his heart. He
knew that he was not going to be leaving his family
well provided for. He had sorted out four hundred
or so of his paintings and had made up albums
of his water-colours and sketches. These he gave
to his daughters, writing their names on the back
to ensure that they could not be sold as a part
of his estate. He told them, 'my dears there won't
be any money for you but I will leave you my paintings
which will one day be worth more than any money
I could ever have hoped to make.'
Death - In August Thomas had
been sketching on the banks of the Deben when
he was approached by the owner of the ironmongers
who asked him, 'why don't you go to your office
to earn some money? - you owe enough.' Thomas
handed him the painting he had been making and
replied that it was worth it all - 'here take
it.' Within a couple of days he was dead - insolvent
but surrounded by an unparalleled collection of
paintings.
Mourned - Sadly missed by those
who knew him well, his family, his friends, his
clients and the officers of the courts where he
worked so hard. Less mourned by the tradesmen
who were owed so much by the family and now knew
that they were not likely to ever be paid. His
friends immediately did what they could to help
his family sort out their debts. But it was very
hard, the girls had been trained for nothing and
took a long while to find a way to live which
befitted their sensibilities.
Obituaries - The papers praised
him for his qualities as devoted father, successful
lawyer, 'Woodbridge Wit', art collector, connoisseur
and prolific artist. Judge Wortledge made this
tribute, 'I had the pleasure of knowing the late
Mr Churchyard for many years, both privately and
in his public capacity. In his private capacity
I have appreciated his refined mind, his genial
spirit, and his courteous manner, but it was chiefly
as an advocate in this court that I valued him:
for while he did his duty fearlessly and ably
to his clients, he never tried to mislead me or
to overreach his opponents by unworthy arts; and
he never wasted the public time by keeping up
useless discussion. In him I have lost a most
valuable aid in the discharge of my duty to the
public in the administration of justice.'
The Suffolk Chronicle wrote: 'the public had lost
a most talented man and an able lawyer; his family
a most kind and affectionate parent; and those
who had the pleasure of his acquaintance, a vivacious
and pleasant companion and friend.'
The Artist
Thomas sold very few of his
paintings during his life-time. After his brief
attempt at becoming a professional artist in London
in the early 1830's he returned home to pick up
his career in law, and dedicated himself to painting
for its own sake. He believed in the value of
his own work, but rarely sort the opinions of
others, after early disappointment.
His daughters also believed in the value of his
art and remained loath to part with more than
a few pieces to particular friends. As each daughter
died her share of the works were passed to the
remaining daughters. Finally the death of Harriet
in 1927 left virtually (maybe 90%) the whole body
of Thomas' life's work in the hands of Charley
the youngest son, and the least honourable of
the family. He put the entire collection of in
excess of 4000 items up for auction.
But Charley Churchyard's final
disservice to the family clouded his father's
true talents and reputation for many years. To
maximise the proceeds from the sale he bundled
up works by his sisters, along with Thomas' genuine
work. People purchasing folders full of drawings
and paintings naturally judged them as very variable
in quality. Some were so good that they were mistaken
for works by Constable, Cotman and Crome. But
some so weak that collectors pronounced Thomas
too amateurish to merit real attention. The whole
sale, including the furniture and china realised
slightly more then £600.
Since Denis Thomas wrote the
first biographical and critical assessment in
1966 Thomas Churchyard's reputation has grown
and finally been recognised. Now that we have
a better view of the works and a clearer understanding
of Thomas' life his genius has been acknowledged
widely. His work is now to be found in many major
public and private collections including: the
Tate Gallery, London; the British Museum; the
V & A Museum Library; the Ashmolean, Oxford;
the Fitzwilliam, Cambridge; Norwich Castle Museum;
Christchurch Mansion, Ipswich; The Alexander Turnbull
Library, New Zealand; Dunedin Art Gallery, New
Zealand; the Huntington Art Gallery, California;
The Putnam Museum, Iowa.
Many of the albums which were
sold on April 11 1927 by Arnott and Everett in
the Lecture Hall Woodbridge remained intact, passed
lovingly down through the families which had bought
them. Some of these albums have recently come
on the market, releasing carefully preserved examples
of Thomas Churchyard's wide talent, with perfect
provenance.
'He knew exactly where he wanted
to put his brush, he never put it down twice and
he always put it in the right place.'
He used: watery greens, black in the blues, purple
distance, sometimes grey, blue thinly painted;
touches of pink in the sky; blue touches in his
foliage. He used oils with a fatty pigment and
he scattered lights rather arbitrarily - small
specks of white or yellow in trees or other masses.
Often the ground was not well prepared and the
grain shows through. (Intentional?) He rarely
signed his work or dated it, although he sometimes
initialled it on the stretcher.
The
Artist's Periods
Early period 1819 - 1834: In London he exhibited
eleven pictures. Most like Constable, or the Norwich
School, when he painted all that he could see
in a simple, natural manner - almost drawing with
the brush, the water-colours at this time were
liquid in pure transparent colour, the oils thinly
painted.
Middle period 1835-1850: Fifteen
pictures exhibited in Ipswich. In 1847 Bernard
Barton said, 'He will dash you off slight and
careless sketches by the dozen, or score, but
for touching and re-touching, or finishing, that
is quite another affair, and has to wait, if ever
it be done at all.'
Later period 1851-1865: Eight
pictures exhibited in Norwich 1852 and some pictures
exhibited in Woodbridge 1865. The paintings tended
to be darker and deeper in expression, more sophisticated.
The forerunners of Expressionism. He painted as
he breathed - without effort, and he painted what
he saw without trying to improve it. The later
water-colours became so physically light in expression
- the merest touches of pencil or colour - that
they were almost casual sketches, but were among
his most sophisticated work - echoing with gentleness
and deliberation a lifetime of painting experience.
The Children
Thomas - 1825-1896 After loss
of his family off coast of Newfoundland he emigrated
to New Zealand where he died.
Ellen - 1826-1909 Noted for her meticulous paintings
of flowers, nests and birds. Less able in her
landscapes.
Emma - 1828-1878 Died very
young. No work has been attributed to her.
Laura - 1830-1891 Her painting
had a dash like her father's. She was the nearest
to him in style, and his boon companion in later
years, often seen out walking with him. She particularly
worked in water-colour.
Anna - 1832-1897 Her landscapes
were often heavy-handed or impulsively slapdash.
She worked in oils and water-colours, and also
produced a large number of sketches.
Bessie - 1834-1913 Although
she was considered rather simple, she was the
first of the daughters to find herself work, and
she managed to save some money from her work.
Pictures by Bessie exist but are relatively unskilled.
Harriet - 1836-1927 She attended
Art School and later taught art at home and at
the Quaker School in Woodbridge. She was very
talented at humorous caricatures and cartoons,
and able to capture a likeness in her portraits.
Mainly working in water-colours, she also produced
genre pictures, children and animals in rural
settings.
Charles - 1837-1838 Died as
a baby.
Kate - 1839-1889 Her subject
matter was similar to Harriet's, capturing the
comic side of life, but with less talent.
Charley - 1841-1929 Failed
at a number of careers. Sponged off his cousins
and sisters whenever he could, ended his life
at the Seckford Almshouse. His work is rather
more coldly executed, hard lines and conventional.
Further reading
Thomas Churchyard of Woodbridge
by Denis Thomas Published 1967
Suffolk School of Painters
by Harold Day Published 1971
Painting The Day by Wallace
Morfey Published 1986
Suffolk Artists 1750-1930 by
Chloe Bennett Ipswich 1991
French Landscapes/Anglais Paysages
exhibition catalogue Ipswich Borough Council 1996
The Search for Thomas Churchyard
by Robert Blake Published 1997
Thomas Churchyard Woodbridge
Artist and Lawyer Compiled by Robert Blake 1998
Thomas Churchyard An Exhibition
and Sale of Original Works to celebrate his bicentenary
David Messum Fine Art Research and Text by Stephen
Reiss OBE 1998
Thomas Churchyard Bicentenary
Exchibition Catalogue by Hugh Belsey Ipswich Borough
Council 1998
|